
Ashcorp Blog
Nobody Wants to Be Managed: What Actually Works in Leading People Today
ᐧ
Oluwatoyosi Oluwatoyinbo
Never in the history of mankind has anybody woken up hoping to be managed.
Okay! Maybe that statement is a bit of an overstatement, particularly because the human race is diverse, with really interesting people and personalities.
However, a large number of people in the workforce hope to be trusted, guided and given room to do the work that they are proud of. Yet many organisations still run on management habits that are archaic and then wonder why engagement is low and talented people keep leaving.
Before we talk about what works today, let’s backtrack a bit to where it all began. A brief history lesson may help us understand people management and its evolution over the generations.

A Brief History of People Management
In 1911, Frederick Taylor published The Principles of Scientific Management, in which he argued that work could be broken into measurable tasks and that workers were most productive when closely supervised. During this period, people were treated as parts of a machine, with the expectation that they would constantly be on the move and churning out results.
Then came a surprise in the 1920s and 1930s, when researchers at the Western Electric plant in Hawthorne, Illinois, found that productivity rose when workers simply felt noticed and cared about, a phenomenon later termed the “Hawthorne effect.” This research, known as the Hawthorne Studies, planted the idea that people are more than their output.
Peter Drucker introduced management by objectives in 1954, shifting the focus from watching activity to agreeing on outcomes. Frederick Herzberg followed in the late 1950s with a finding that remains relevant today: pay can prevent dissatisfaction, but recognition, achievement and growth are what truly motivate.
From the 1980s, personnel departments evolved into Human Resources, and in the last decade, the pandemic, remote work and a new generation of employees have pushed the conversation even further.
The lesson from this history is simple: the more we understand people, the better they perform. I have seen this play out in real life.
What Actually Works in Leading People Today
1. Start With Trust, Not Control
At one point in my career, I worked in an organisation where a manager demanded that every single email communication going out of the team be sent to them for approval first. It did not matter what the purpose of the email was, who the recipients were (even more concerning if the recipient was an executive or a senior employee), or how urgent it was; as long as it was a communication going out of the team, the manager had to review it.
Your first thought may be:
“Well, maybe the team members are not experienced”
“Maybe there’s been a situation where a damning communication has been sent without the manager’s knowing”
Believe me when I say that was not the situation. The team members were experienced, highly capable professionals. The only variable was that the manager had just been promoted to the role. Maybe that was the cause of the constant paranoia and anxious need to control every little detail.
The result was a team that spent more time waiting for unnecessary approvals than actually doing their jobs, and the best people quietly started interviewing elsewhere. At one point, literally all the team members had one foot out of the business.
Contrast that with other outstanding managers I have been privileged to work alongside, who simply say to their teams, “Tell me what you need, and tell me early when something is going wrong.” Their teams delivered more with less fear, were extremely accountable, and had great confidence in doing their jobs and owning their space.
This is backed by evidence. When Google studied 180 of its own teams in Project Aristotle, the single most important factor in team success was psychological safety, a concept developed by Harvard professor Amy Edmondson. It is the shared belief that you can speak up, ask questions and admit mistakes without being punished.
As managers, when someone raises a problem, thank them first and solve it second. According to B.F. Skinner’s 1938 reinforcement theory, people repeat whatever behaviour gets rewarded.
2. Make Expectations Painfully Clear
In recent years, a manager asked me to support a performance improvement plan for an employee described as “not getting it”. When I asked what success looked like in that role, the answers from the manager and the employee were completely different. This revealed that the employee had never been the problem. Ambiguity was.
Research consistently shows that knowing what is expected at work is one of the foundations of engagement and employee satisfaction. Clarity is not micromanagement. It is leadership.
Two tested frameworks may help here:
SMART goals: Specific, Measurable, Achievable, Relevant and Time-bound. They turn “do better” into something a person can actually act on.
OKRs (Objectives and Key Results): This framework connects individual effort to company priorities, so people understand why their work matters.
Ask every team member to write down, in their own words, what success looks like in their role. Compare it with yours. The gaps will surprise you. Organisations and managers must therefore ensure that they clearly communicate expectations and document success metrics for each role.
3. Give Specific Feedback Early and Often
Many managers avoid feedback because they fear the conversation will be awkward and uncomfortable. But silence is not neutral; if anything, it leaves people guessing and allows small issues to become large ones.
The SBI model from the Center for Creative Leadership makes feedback easier to deliver:
Situation: Describe when and where it happened.
Behaviour: State what you observed, without assumptions about intent.
Impact: Explain the effect it had on the team, the client or the outcome.
For example: “In yesterday’s client meeting, the presentation ran for forty minutes. The client seemed to lose focus before we reached the proposal.” This is factual, calm and actionable.
Kim Scott's Radical Candour framework adds an important balance: care personally and challenge directly. Challenge without care feels cruel. Care without challenge becomes dishonesty.
As a manager, learn to give feedback within 48 hours of the behaviour. Do not save it for the annual review.
4. Manage the Person, Not the Position
Imagine two members of a team joining within a month of each other. One may need daily direction, while the other may become visibly frustrated if checked in on too often. Managing them the same way may lead to failure for both.
This is the core idea of Situational Leadership, developed by Paul Hersey and Ken Blanchard. The right management style depends on a person’s competence and confidence for a particular task. A new hire may need direction, a developing employee needs coaching, a capable but cautious one needs support, and an expert needs delegation.
The most reliable tool for this is the traditional one-on-one meeting. A weekly or fortnightly conversation of thirty minutes, focused on the employee’s priorities, blockers and wellbeing, remains one of the most effective management practices there is. It must be protected. A one-on-one that is repeatedly cancelled sends a clear message about how much the person matters.
Let the employee set the agenda. Ask, “What is the one thing I could do differently to support you?” Then act on the answer.
5. Build Growth into the Job
In my previous article, I wrote about the silent exit and the retention equation: Do I matter here? Can I grow here? Am I respected here? Growth is where many managers fall short because it feels like something to handle “later”.
In the past, I conducted a stay interview with a high performer who had never given any sign of unhappiness. Within ten minutes, she admitted that she had not had a real career conversation in two years and had begun to look around. This, of course, was a shocking revelation to the HR team.
A stay interview simply asks current employees what keeps them, what might make them leave and what they would change. It costs nothing and tells you what an exit interview tells you, but while there is still time to act.
According to Herzberg’s findings, a salary review may stop someone from complaining, but it rarely makes them care. Meaningful work, visible progress and genuine appreciation do that. Many managers assume they cannot afford to retain talent, when what people often want most is attention and a path forward.
Hold a career conversation with every team member at least twice a year. Ask where they want to be in three years, then agree on one practical step towards that goal, such as a stretch assignment, a mentor or a course.

Putting It Into Practice
You do not need to adopt everything at once. You can start by:
Scheduling one-on-ones with every direct report
Clarifying expectations in writing with each person, using SMART goals or OKRs
Practising the SBI model, running stay interviews and holding career conversations
Asking for feedback on your own management and showing people that you acted on it
In conclusion, if you can only change one thing, make it consistency. Employees can forgive an imperfect manager, but they struggle with an unpredictable one. We must learn to show up for the one-on-ones, give the feedback we promised and follow through on what we say.
Gallup research, summarised in the State of the American Manager: Analytics and Advice for Leaders (2015), has found that managers account for at least 70% of the variance in team engagement. That is a sobering figure. It means that, for most employees, the manager is the organisation and its culture.
Management has travelled a long way, from stopwatches and supervision to trust and coaching. The tools are tested, and the evidence is clear. What remains is the willingness to apply them consistently and with heart.
Because, at the end of the day, people do not just work for companies. They work for managers who see them, hear them and help them grow.
Be the manager people are glad they had.
More Posts


